Five Numbers, Two Answers, and the Divisor Nobody Asks About
The standard deviation of 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 is either 1.4142 or 1.5811, and offering one of them without asking which question you are answering is the only wrong move. The sum of squared deviations is 10 either way, so everything turns on whether you divide it by 5 or by 4. Bessel's correction makes the variance unbiased and leaves the standard deviation biased low by about six percent at this sample size, and a third divisor beats both of them if you optimise for mean squared error instead.