Count the Outcomes Before You Count on a Hedge
A share at 100 that jumps to either 80 or 130 gives a call an exact price of 12, from two equations in two unknowns and no probability at all. Let the jump size be random, so 110 is also reachable, and that same hedge pays 18 where the option pays 10 while no other portfolio does better. The arbitrage-free prices then fill the whole interval from 20/3 to 12, and the obstruction turns out to be the kink in the payoff rather than the number of states.