A 100 Basis Point Rally Pays 7.79 Percent or 4.21, and Only One Curve Bends the Right Way
In a rally you want positive convexity, and a mortgage pool has negative convexity, because the borrowers hold the right to prepay and you are short that option. Modelled as a ten-year 6 percent bond minus a three-year call struck at 105, the straight bond has convexity plus 68.8 and the pool minus 177.4, and doubling a rally from 100 to 200 basis points takes the bond from 7.79 percent to 16.35 while the pool goes only from 4.21 to 6.13. The pool still gains, so the reflex is right about the sign and wrong about the size, and the single parameter set in 108 with positive curvature is one whose prepayment option is far out of the money.